Sevilla, Héctor - The Best Interest of the Child in the Juvenile Justice

Description
This paper has been draftedto point at the specific application of this principle within the criminal law, and to indicate thatfollowing it up is the best way to accomplish a juvenile justice system engaged to theConvention of the Rights of the Child (CRC). (English Only)

Please download to get full document.

View again

of 6
All materials on our website are shared by users. If you have any questions about copyright issues, please report us to resolve them. We are always happy to assist you.
Information
Category:

Documents

Publish on:

Views: 0 | Pages: 6

Extension: PDF | Download: 0

Share
Tags
Transcript
    A ÈLWN[ H TÀC \ BTHII@ \ @IHC@\   W AB KB\W HCWB[B\W ND WAB LAHIG HC WAB O RTBCHIB O R\WHLB (B I HCWB[È\ \RUB[HN[ GBI CHÐN ,  I@ CHÐ@ X BI @GNIB\LBCWB BC I@ O R\WHLH@ U BC@I GB @ GNIB\LBCWB\ )    Ouvbchib Gbtbcthnc Lbctbr hc Chl`r`mu`. Uantnmr`pa ky Fhlabi [bgncgn. Thsht www.fhlabirbgncgn.lnf tn vhbw fnrb pantnmr`pas    U`mb | 0 H CW[NGRLWHNC   Ouvbchib lnurts `rb cnt sblncg-li`ss lrhfhc`i `mbclhbs (Dbig, 0888) tn prnlbss ynucmstbrs ta`t a`vb g`f`mbg snlhbty. Hc sphtb nd tab stufkihcm kinljs, ouvbchib lnurts `rb spblh`i ousthlb bcththbs ta`t `rb suppnsbg tn prntblt fhcnrs drnf `ii ta`t f`y ib`g tabf tn lnffht fnrb hcdr`lthncs: ouvbchib lnurts `rb ` fb`cs tn lnctbct `cg rbgulb tab puchthvb pnwbr nd tab st`tb hc nrgbr tn rb`ihzb ` gbfnlr`ly (_`dd`rnch, @i`mh` & \inj`r, ;552). @ st`tb ta`t rb`snc`kiy bcsurbs ta`t lahigrbc `cg tbbc`mbrs whii cnt suddbr kbl`usb nd hts pnwbr, hs ` st`tb ta`t gnbs cnt trb`t fhcnrs `s sblncg-li`ss lrhfhc`is, kut `s uchqub hcghvhgu`is ta`t ucgbr p`rthlui`r lncghthncs a`vb krnjbc tab i`w: ht hs `isn ` st`tb ta`t hcstb`g nd ushcm tab strncmbst s`clthncs `v`hi`kib, lannsbs tab fnst `pprnprh`tb trb`tfbct tn gbvh`tb lahigrbc drnf lrhfb: ` st`tb nd tahs typb kuhigs ` c`thnc ta`t pr`lthlbs auf`c rhmats ky rblnmchzhcm ta`t hts ynuta cbbgs spblh`i `ttbcthnc `cg prnvhgbs ht `pprnprh`tbiy. Kut anw hs ht pnsshkib ta`t ` st`tb gbvbinps tahs `pprn`la hc tab lrhfhc`i i`w dhbig> \ula `hf hs pnsshkib ky pursuhcm tab kbst hctbrbst nd lahigrbc `cg `gnibslbcts. Wahs p`pbr a`s kbbc gr`dtbg tn pnhct `t tab spblhdhl `ppihl`thnc nd tahs prhclhpib whtahc tab lrhfhc`i i`w, `cg tn hcghl`tb ta`t dniinwhcm ht up hs tab kbst w`y tn `llnfpihsa ` ouvbchib ousthlb systbf bcm`mbg tn tab Lncvbcthnc nd tab [hmats nd tab Lahig (L[L). G BDHCHWHNC   Kbdnrb ghslusshcm anw tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig fust ruib tab ouvbchib  ousthlb systbfs `cg anw wnrjs hc tab ibmhsi`thnc nd snfb st`tbs nd tab @fbrhl`c lncthcbct, ht hs hfpnrt`ct tn bxpnsb tab spblhdhl la`r`ltbrs tahs prhclhpib t`jbs wabc ht a`s tn kb `ppihbg tn tab ouvbchib lrhfhc`i lnurts. Wab Hctbrc`thnc`i A`cgknnj nd Ouvbchib Ousthlb inl`tbs twn hfpnrt`ct lht`thncs rbi`tbg tn tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig kbdnrb `cy ntabr tbxt. Ibt‘s rb`g tabf `cg st`rt putthcm tnmbtabr tab bibfbcts ta`t gbdhcb tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig rbm`rghcm tab ouvbchib ousthlb. ’Hc `ii `lthncs lnclbrchcm lahigrbc, wabtabr ucgbrt`jbc ky pukihl nr prhv`tb snlh`i wbid`rb hcsthtuthncs, lnurts nd i`w, `gfhchstr`thvb `utanrhthbs nr ibmhsi`thvb knghbs, tab kbst hctbrbsts nd tab lahig sa`ii kb ` prhf`ry lncshgbr`thnc. Lncvbcthnc nc tab [hmats nd tab Lahig (RC Gnl. @rt. <, 0st p`r`. (0818))  @itanuma ynucm pbnpib sanuig kb abig rbspncshkib dnr tabhr gbihcqubct `lts, `ii s`clthncs `cg hctbrvbcthncs sanuig kb dnlusbg nc tabhr rba`khiht`thnc `cg rbhctbmr`thnc hc snlhbty `cg fbbt tab spblhdhl cbbgs wahla hfpbgb tabhr mrnwhcm  U`mb | ; up hctn rbspncshkib lhthzbcs. ]nrjhcm mrnup nc Ouvbchib Ousthlb (Burnpb`c \nlhbty nd Lrhfhcninmy)‖ (Oucmbr-t`s & Gbljbr, ;551? 2). F`cy bxpbrts, ihjb Gb i` Lubst` (hc Ouvbchib I`w Thni`tnrs, Auf`c [hmats, `cg tab Gbvbinpfbct nd Cbw Ouvbchib Ousthlb \ystbfs, ;554) `cg Bstabr Dbrcàcgbz  “ rbsb`rlabr nd tab Hcvbsthm`thnc Lbctbr nc Lrhfhcninmy nd tab Rchvbrshty nd L`sthii`-I` F`cla` (\p`hc)  “  `mrbb ta`t tab L[L gnbs cnt prnvhgb ` gbdhchthnc nd wa`t tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig hs, taus hts us`mb f`y kb sukoblt tn ghddbrbct hctbrprbt`thncs. Anwbvbr, tab ruib cufkbr 05 nd tab Lngb nd tab Lahiganng `cg @gnibslbclb nd Chl`r`mu` hcghl`tbs ta`t bvbry `lthnc d`vnrhcm tab payshl`i, psylaninmhl`i, luitur`i, `cg snlh`i gbvbinpfbct nd ynucmstbrs `llnrghcm tn tab bvniuthnc nd tabhr l`p`lhthbs hs `c `ppihl`thnc nd tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig. Wahs gbdhchthnc ihfhts tab ibcmta, inl`thnc, `cg hctbcshty nd tab hctbrvbcthnc nd tab st`tb hc tab ihdb nd tab `gnibslbcts hc trnukib whta tab i`w. Ht hs hfpnrt`ct tn rb`ihzb ta`t tab `ppihl`thnc nd tabsb lnclbpts tn tab lrhfhc`i i`w `rb cnt `sjhcm us tn p`y `ttbcthnc nciy tn tansb `gnibslbcts ta`t gn cnt kba`vb `llnrghcm tn tab i`w. Ht hs `isn hcliugbg `cy `lt cnt gncb ky fhcnrs kut `ddblthcm fhcnrs. Lu`rbzf` & _`p`t` (;557) mhvb us `c bxlbiibct bx`fpib nd tahs: taby `c`iyzb ` rblbct `goughl`thnc hc Chl`r`mu` hc wahla ` lnurt gblhgbg cnt tn hfprhsnc ` fntabr `s abr hcl`rlbr`thnc wnuig `ddblt tab gbvbinpfbct nd abr twn jhgs: `s tab fntabr `cg tab lahigrbc lncsthtutbg ` inw hclnfb d`fhiy whtanut tab pnsshkhihty nd kbhcm `sshstbg ky `cy rbi`thvb tn t`jb l`rb nd tab fhcnrs, tab lnurt gblhgbg tn mr`ct tab fntabr prnk`thnc `itanuma sab ghg cnt fbbt tab rbquhrbfbcts tn nkt`hc ht. Hd tab lnurt a`g f`gb hts gblhshnc ky dniinwhcm strhltiy tab lrhfhc`i i`w, tab lahigrbc wnuig cnt a`vb a`g tab nppnrtuchty tn a`vb tabhr gbvbinpfbct`i cbbgs s`thsdhbg whtahc tab kbst bcvhrncfbct pnsshkib dnr tabf, tabhr d`fhiy. A`vhcm t`jbc hctn `llnuct tabsb prbvhnus hgb`s, tab hctbrvbcthnc nd tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig hc tab ouvbchib ousthlb systbfs ghspnsbs ta`t kbdnrb `cy `ltnr nd tab  ouvbchib ousthlb systbf -h.b. lnurts, prnsblutnrs, `cg `gvnl`tbs- hssub `cy gblhshnc rbm`rghcm ucgbr`mb, taby fust lncshgbr hd sula gblhshnc f`y `ddblt tab gbvbinpfbct nd lahigrbc `cg `gnibslbcts ghrbltiy  “ wabc taby `rb tab ncbs prnsblutbg  “  nr hcghrbltiy  “ wabc `c `goughl`thnc rblbhvbg ky ntabrs f`y hfp`lt tabhr ihvbs  “ . W AB KB\W HCWB[B\W ND WAB LAHIG HC WAB ORTBCHIB OR\WHLB   \n d`r, tab slnpb nd tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig `ppihbg tn bvbry gblhshnc `cg `lthnc bcgnrsbg ky `cy ousthlb `mbct a`s kbbc li`rhdhbg. Cbvbrtabibss, ht hs sthii cblbss`ry tn lnffbct anw tab cbm`thvb bddblts nd tab lrhfhc`i ousthlb systbfs f`y kb `vnhgbg rbm`rghcm  U`mb | < tab lahiganng `cg `gnibslbclb: ht hs fy lncshgbr`thnc ta`t ghvbrthcm fhcnrs drnf tab pnwbr nd tab st`tb `cg tab lrhfb hs tab w`y tn `lahbvb tahs. Kut wa`t hs ghvbrshnc> ’Ghvbrshnc hs   (…) tab prnlbss nd ghrblthcm ` ouvbchib nddbcgbr drnf dnrf`i  prnlbsshcm tarnuma tab ouvbchib lnurt tn `c `itbrc`thvb prnlbss ta`t d`vnrs `c hcdnrf`i rbsniuthnc ta`t f`y hcliugb sbbjhcm lnffuchty-k`sbg `sshst`clb dnr tab fhcnr, sula `s ynuta gbvbinpfbct prnmr`fs nr tutnrhcm‖   (Juplahj, ;55<? 17) (@kr`fsnc (;505), Oucmbr-t`s & Gbljbr (;551), Dbig (0888), `cg Dbisthcbr & Dbbst (;554) trb`t ghvbrshnc hc tab s`fb w`y). Ghvbrshnc hs tab kbst w`y tn turc tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig hctn ` rb`ihty, kbl`usb ht `vnhgs ta`t ynucmstbrs lncthcub ` ghrblt p`ta tn ` ihdb nd lrhfb ky t`jhcm tabf `w`y drnf bvbry pnsshkib lrhfhcnmbchl d`ltnr ta`t f`y `ddblt tabhr gbvbinpfbct turchcm tabf hctn pbnpib l`p`kib tn lnffht lrhfbs. Ky Hfpbghcm ta`t taby mn tn prhsncs, ky sbcghcm tabf tn rba`khiht`thnc prnmr`fs, ky onhchcm tabf tn bgul`thnc`i lnursbs, `cg ky abiphcm tabf tn a`vb pnshthvb anfb `cg lnffuc`i bcvhrncfbcts, ynutas f`y s`thsdy sullbssduiiy tabhr gbvbinpfbct`i cbbgs `cg tabrbdnrb bst`kihsa ghst`clb drnf tab bibfbcts ta`t ib`g tabf tn lrhfb `cg tn kb prnsblutbg hc tab  ouvbchib ousthlb systbf. Lncvbrsbiy, ky pbrfhtthcm ta`t ouvbchib nddbcgbrs rblbhvb tab s`fb s`clthncs ta`c `guits, ky sbcghcm tabf tn hcl`rlbr`thnc systbfs, ky gbprhvhcm tabf drnf tabhr d`fhihbs, `cg ky kbhcm sthmf`thzbg ky tabhr lnffuchthbs, ynucm pbnpib ihvb lncghthncs ta`t lbrt`hciy gn cnt abip tabf tn kuhig ` ihdb whtanut gbihcqubcly. Ghvbrshnc systbfs gbvh`tb tbbcs drnf ncb rb`ihty ta`t a`rfs tabf tn `cntabr wabrb tabhr cbbgs l`c kb s`thsdhbg. Wabsb `rb tab rb`sncs way ghvbrshnc hs tab kbst w`y tn rb`ihzb tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig. W AB KB\W HCWB[B\W ND WAB LAHIG HC WAB IBMH\I@WHNC ND LNRCW[HB\ ND WAB @ FB[HL@C LNCWHCBCW   Ht a`s kbbc `irb`gy sbttibg wa`t tab prhclhpib nd tab kbst hctbrbst nd tab lahig fb`cs `cg anw ht nvbri`ps tab `lthvhty nd tab ouvbchib ousthlb systbf tarnuma ghvbrthcm ynucmstbrs, `cg cnw ` rbvhshnc nd tab ibmhsi`thnc nd snfb lnuctrhbs nd tab @fbrhl`c lncthcbct whii dniinw tn cntb `cg
Related Search
Similar documents
View more...
We Need Your Support
Thank you for visiting our website and your interest in our free products and services. We are nonprofit website to share and download documents. To the running of this website, we need your help to support us.

Thanks to everyone for your continued support.

No, Thanks